Fw: [Islam] Discard using photo of human face in Id card, rather use finger print.
Forwarded Message -----
From: Muhammad Habibullah <way2peace786@yahoo.com>
To:
Sent: Saturday, June 2, 2012 4:07 PM
Subject: Fw: [Islam] Discard using photo of human face in Id card, rather use finger print.
From: Abdul Hamid Malik <abdulhamidmalik34@gmail.com>
To: Muhammad Habibullah <way2peace786@yahoo.com>
Sent: Tuesday, March 20, 2012 5:32 PM
Subject: Re: [Islam-in-Urdu] Discard using photo of human face in Id card, rather use finger print.
Aslaamun Alaikum.
Jazak Allah Khairan
On Mon, Mar 19, 2012 at 3:58 PM, Muhammad Habibullah <way2peace786@yahoo.com> wrote:
wa 'alaikumus Salam wa Rwa'hmatullahi wa Baraakatuhu,
I am so glad to have your reply which is so much thoughtful. At a glance, it may seem that you are right but the reality is opposite. Why?
Because:
1. preparing a photo is so much time consuming. you need a camera, you need to process it and then you have to print. You need some separate arrangements. I am not considering any forgery or external manipulation in photography.
2. In case of travellers or public, matching of fingerprints is not one to many rather you have to match one to one which is a matter of seconds for fingerprint scanner. Here, the examiner has to examine the concerned person's fingerprint with a scanner with the fingerprint of that person put on a Id card or in a database archive. And offcourse, it is 100% accurate and dependable without any doubt. But in this case, photography is not at all reliable as the examiner has to look at the photography and at the person with keen eyes and sometimes, many fellons cheat the examiner with make up, dress-up, hair style etc.
3. In case of crime detection, finger print is undoubtedly best choice though here one particular fingerprint is matched with the archive of fingerprints which may take time but here time is not a factor. And offcourse, with modern computerized system, it is more accurate, dependable and no manual work is required. You can google finger print matching and see how much advance this types of science is. Whereas, the photography matching is quite hard and not at all dependable and need all time manual work.
4. Regarding the cost, just check the price of photography( or cctv) and the price of a finger print scanner. I am doing a project on this issue. Making an ID Card with photo of human face is much more costly for a group of people than a Id card(without photo) with finger print scanner machine. Even in case of accessing, you dont need the card as your own finger works as the access key.
Hope, this is helpful for you.
Ma'a Assalaama
From: Abdul Hamid Malik <abdulhamidmalik34@gmail.com>
To: way2peace786@yahoo.com
Sent: Monday, March 19, 2012 5:11 AM
Subject: Re: [Islam-in-Urdu] Discard using photo of human face in Id card, rather use finger print.
:
Aslaamun Alaikum.
Irrespect to Deen there is one important social point:
Identification from finger print is a highly technically sophisticated job and may take [in my view] if not hours but some minutes while from photo it is a matter of seconds.
1. Where mass movements are involved you can assess the delays faced by travellers or public.
2. Where it is on local basis like small business or private dealings it will be too costly.
On Sun, Mar 18, 2012 at 6:12 AM, Muhammad Habibullah <way2peace786@yahoo.com> wrote:
Finger Print is the Best method for Identification and Security
Because:
1. Finger print of every person is unique, that is, no two persons have same finger print
2. Finger print does not change with time. Human face changes with dress up, hairstyle, age and artificial makeups. So, photo of human face is not useful in the long run.
3. Finger print is very easy and less time consuming to take. Someone needs only some ink to imprint his fingerprint. Whereas, photography is complex and time consuming
4. Cost of Finger Print is really minimal.
5. Scanning of Finger Print is easy.
6.Matching of Finger Print is easy. In automated computerized system, does not need manual assistance at all. but Matching of photography is really hard thing and direct human viewing is required most of the times.
7. Finally, photography of human is harwaam and finger print is allowed.
So, in all respects, avoid using photo for detection and security, rather use finger print which far more dependable, accurate and ensure practical security.
Discard using photo of human face in Id card, rather use finger print.
__._,_.___
--
From:
[Pak-Friends] Group Member
Visit Group:
http://groups.google.com/group/Karachi-786 Subscription:
http://groups.google.com/group/karachi-786/subscribe ===========================================================
¸,.-~*'¨¯¨'*·~-.¸¸,.-~*'[PäK¤.¸.¤F®ï£ñD§]'*·~-.¸¸,.-~*'¨¯¨'*·~-.¸
===========================================================
All members are expected to follow these Simple Rules:
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
Be Careful in Islamic Discussions;
Bad language and insolence against Prophets (and / or their companions, Islamic Scholars, and saints) is an Instant ban.
Abuse of any kind (to the Group, or it's Members) shall not be tolerated.
SPAM, Advertisement, and Adult messages are NOT allowed.
This is not Dating / Love Group, avoid sending personnel messages to group members.
Do not post anything linked to (or in favor of) facebook.
Thanks
